Published on November 5, 2018
With the U.S. economy now in its ninth year of expansion, investors have become wary of growth stocks and their higher multiples. The ongoing market volatility has increased these concerns, but research from Cornerstone Macro suggests that a slowdown in the economy may in fact be favorable for growth companies.
We have always believed that growth stocks belong in any long-term asset allocation. Our logic is simple – over time, companies with steadily increasing earnings should deliver higher returns than slow growing companies.
Nonetheless, many investors avoid growth stocks, fearing they are little more than well-disguised momentum stocks. Those concerns are elevated right now, as the recent market selloff has investors worried the long-running economic expansion is finally slowing down, potentially causing growth stocks to fall faster than more defensive value stocks.
A recent report from Cornerstone Macro argues that the opposite is true. The authors agree with the concerns about a potential slowdown, but they believe that a cooling economy is actually quite favorable for growth firms. Moreover, the authors claim that the traditional risk relationship between growth and value is changing.
As the Market Cools, Earnings Take Priority
According to the Cornerstone report, “History shows that the sweet-spot for growth, cyclically speaking, is the period that follows a peak in economic prospects.” The chart below shows the three phases that typically occur after a peak in economic activity.
The x-axis shows the number of months before and after the economy hits its apex, as measured by the Institute for Supply Management’s Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI). Citing a recent decline in the PMI following a multi-year peak, Cornerstone argues that the U.S. economy is at the beginning of a sustained period of slower growth. They believe PMI is a leading economic indicator signaling that the long-running expansion is likely to lose steam as the Fed pushes up rates and inflationary pressures mount.
They argue that a slowdown favors growth firms because it is a more challenging environment in which to operate, significantly reducing the number of companies that are able to deliver steadily increasing earnings. And historically, those that are able to do it are almost always growth firms, as they are less sensitive to the state of the macro economy. These companies should stand out from the crowd, which will increase demand for their shares and push up their stock price.
Cornerstone believes the process is already underway. Using the S&P 500 as a proxy for the broader market, they show that breadth (as measured by the number of stocks above their 150 day moving average) has declined since 2016 while the price of the index has steadily risen.
Their conclusion is that the gains are driven by a progressively smaller set of growth companies whose share prices are rallying disproportionately.
Structural Shifts Should Continue to Favor Growth
The authors also point out that growth has beaten value over the past decade*, and they argue that the key post-crisis structural shift that has driven this dynamic is likely to continue.
Specifically, consumer debt as a portion of GDP has fallen roughly 20% in the past decade, and the authors believe this is the major reason quarter-over-quarter GDP growth has been materially slower during the current recovery than during other expansionary periods. The present growth rate is roughly half the rate from 1980-1999, and roughly 75% of the growth rate from 2000-2008.
Reduced GDP growth has translated to slower top line expansion for the broader market, pushing investors toward growth companies. They expect this trend to intensify as the economy slows in the near-to-medium term.
Risk Profiles Are Changing
Perhaps the most intriguing component of Cornerstone’s research is their claim that the traditional risk relationship between growth and value has changed.
Using beta as a proxy for risk, the authors show that the relationship between P/E and beta has essentially reversed itself over the past 15 years. Specifically, high P/E stocks now have a low beta and vice-versa.
Cornerstone’s analysis offers an interesting perspective that combines conventional wisdom with a contrarian view. They agree with the prevailing sentiment that the current economic expansion is likely to slow down, but they have the uncommon belief that such a change would actually be good for growth stocks.
James L. Callinan
Vice President & Portfolio Manager
James L. CallinanView Bio
James L. Callinan
Vice President & Portfolio Manager
Jim Callinan graduated from Harvard College (B.A. Economics), New York University (M.S. Accounting) and Harvard Business School (M.B.A.). Mr. Callinan holds the Chartered Financial Analyst designation.
Prior to joining Osterweis Capital Management in 2016, Mr. Callinan managed the Emerging Growth Partnership, LP, a concentrated small cap growth strategy he founded at RS and transitioned to his own firm. Before that, he was Co-Founder & Chief Investment Officer at RS Investments. He also co-founded the RS Growth Group LLC at Robertson Stephens Investment Management in 1996 and managed the RS Emerging Growth Fund from 1996 until 2010.
He began his career at Putnam Investments as an equity research analyst in 1987 and served as portfolio manager for the Putnam OTC Emerging Growth Fund from 1994 to 1996.
Mr. Callinan is an Executive Committee member of the Bay Area Make-A-Wish Foundation Advisory Board, the Weatherbie Capital (an Alger Company) Advisory Board and the Friends of Harvard Football Board.
Mr. Callinan is a principal of the firm and a Portfolio Manager for the emerging growth strategy. He is also a Portfolio Manager for the flexible balanced strategy.
Invest With UsLearn More
Opinions expressed are those of the author, are subject to change at any time, are not guaranteed and should not be considered investment advice.
The charts and graphs included in this article were all provided by Cornerstone Macro.
Mutual fund investing involves risk. Principal loss is possible. The Osterweis Emerging Opportunity Fund may invest in unseasoned companies, which involve additional risks such as abrupt or erratic price movements. The Fund may invest in small and mid-sized companies, which may involve greater volatility than large-sized companies. The Fund may invest in IPOs and unseasoned companies that are in the early stages of their development and may pose more risk compared to more established companies. The Fund may invest in ETFs, which involve risks that do not apply to conventional funds. Higher turnover rates may result in increased transaction costs, which could impact performance. From time to time, the Fund may have concentrated positions in one or more sectors subjecting the Fund to sector emphasis risk. The Fund may invest in foreign and emerging market securities, which involve greater volatility and political, economic and currency risks and differences in accounting methods. These risks may increase for emerging markets.
Holdings and allocations may change at any time due to ongoing portfolio management. References to specific investments should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell the securities. Current and future holdings are subject to risk.
The ISM Manufacturing Index monitors employment, production, inventories, new orders and supplier deliveries. The Index is based on surveys of more than 300 manufacturing firms by the Institute for Supply Management (ISM).
Beta is a measure of the volatility, or systematic risk, of a security or a portfolio in comparison to the market as a whole.
Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio is the ratio of the stock price to the trailing 12 months diluted EPS.
The S&P 500 Index is an unmanaged index that is widely regarded as the standard for measuring large-cap U.S. stock market performance. The index does not incur expenses, is not available for investment, and includes the reinvestment of dividends.
The Osterweis Funds are available by prospectus only. The Funds’ investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses must be considered carefully before investing. The summary and statutory prospectuses contain this and other important information about the Funds. You may obtain a summary or statutory prospectus by calling toll free at (866) 236-0050, or by visiting www.osterweis.com/statpro. Please read the prospectus carefully before investing to ensure the Fund is appropriate for your goals and risk tolerance.
Osterweis Capital Management is the adviser to the Osterweis Funds, which are distributed by Quasar Distributors, LLC.